The 5 Years Before You Retire: Retirement Planning When You Need It the Most | Chapter 6: Taxes and Your Retirement Income

We’ve added to all our clients list of goals “Don’t tip the IRS.” It’s shocking how different the amount of total lifetime tax the same person could pay if income and assets remain the same. Working with us does not allow you to evade taxes (that’s illegal), but we will work to minimize your lifetime tax (with a couple caveats, below).
The tax code itself isn’t simple – it spans roughly 3,000-70,000 pages, depending on how you count (the higher number is more accurate). As Judge Learned Hand famously said, “Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury; there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes.” In other words, it is perfectly acceptable to arrange your finances in accordance with the tax code to reduce your taxes. This is the goal of the tax planning we do here at Brockmann Financial.
In Birken’s book, she outlines that each of these assets and income sources all have different tax rules
Pre-tax retirement accounts such as IRAs and 401k
Tax free retirement accounts such as Roth IRAs and Roth 401ks
Nonqualified annuities (separate rules for accumulation and when taking distributions)
Non-retirement accounts that hold stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs
Social Security income
Just looking at the example of how to calculate Social Security will make your head spin. It’s assumed that whether you do your taxes yourself or with a CPA, software is being used to handle the calculations. That’s not the issue at hand; the issue is that how these income sources come into play depend on all the others, and without coordinating both in the present and with plans for the future, you will almost surely end up paying more in taxes than you need to.
While there are many tax-reducing tactics, the main one is tax bracket management. If we can shift income that you’d pay 22% on to another time where you’d pay 12% instead, that simple move saves you 10% of your funds. This shows up in your tax brackets while working and saving for retirement, and comparing that to what we anticipate you’d be in during retirement. Beyond this, it’s common that retirees first spend from their non-retirement assets, which do not show up dollar-for-dollar on your tax return. On paper, it looks like income is low, which we use to our advantage to shift assets from pre-tax to tax-free (this is called a Roth conversion) before we have to pay a higher rate in a future year.
Another savings opportunity is for clients who are planning to retire before 65, when they are eligible for Medicare. These clients obtain health insurance coverage through the Marketplace, otherwise known as Affordable Care Act or Obamacare plans. The premiums you pay depend on what your income is on paper (not what you’re spending), and so shifting income could save thousands of dollars in insurance premiums. While not technically a tax, this additional cost needs to be considered in someone’s plans.
There are two important caveats when we discuss tax planning and reducing lifetime tax.
Firstly, saving in taxes is always done as secondary to providing the life (and income needed) on our clients goals list. The goal of not tipping the IRS is below other life goals. The best way to avoid paying taxes is to save as much as you can into tax-deferred assets, never spend them, and give them all away to charity to avoid any taxes. This results in the lowest taxes, and likely does not match your goals. Avoiding spending and enjoying your wealth because you have to give 30% to taxes is putting the cart before the horse. Enjoying 70% is better than 0%.
Secondly, we say “reduce lifetime taxes” even though this is oversimplified. For example, if a 30 year old has $20,000 saved in a pre-tax IRA and is in the 24% federal tax bracket, they could convert this (pay the taxes now and have it grow tax free), paying 24% of $20,000 or $4,800 in federal taxes. Instead, if they allow this to grow tax deferred for 30 years until they retire and the $20,000 is now worth 8x, or $160,000. Let’s assume in retirement they’re in the 12% bracket (or at least have some years they will be, which is very common). If they spend the $160,000 and pay 12% tax, they’ll owe $19,200, which at first glance is much higher than $4,800. In reality, it would be better to pay the $19,200 than the $4,800. Here’s why: if you pay $4,800 on the $20,000, you have $15,200 left. This will grow at the same rate, and so once it’s 8x larger, you’ll have $121,600 to spend. On the other hand, if you grow it tax free and have $160,000, then spend $19,200 in taxes, you have $140,800 to spend. This is why it’s not about reducing the actual tax dollars paid, but instead maximizing the funds kept in your pocket to spend at the desired time, whether in retirement or sooner.
Projecting, planning, and coordinating lifetime taxes is part of what we do. It’s also the reason we’ve partnered with a CPA firm so that we can help prepare and file our clients taxes annually. The ability to see all your tax documents, and to review your return before it’s filed is very helpful toward our end of lowering your lifetime tax bill, so that you can enjoy a happy and successful retirement.
Let us know
How do you feel when you owe taxes vs getting a refund when you file your annual tax return?
Is it easy to pay (less) taxes now to avoid paying more later?
Until next time, happy reading!

